Who has the best lobster roll in Brooklyn? I don't know but I love a good lobster roll. There are some that do the trick and there are some that change your life. I would say the bacon lobster roll from Red Hook Lobster Pound, in Brooklyn NYC is one that you should definitely try. I had it recently and I fell in love. Mixing the smoky saltiness of thickly sliced bacon with the light fluffy lobster meat on a brioche bun is all you need in this life of sin!